By Stephen D. Bowling
It was a cold morning, and two Breathitt County hunters were ready for their hunt.
Squirrel season was in, and Mac Sizemore and Darrell Allen planned to slip into a stand of hickory trees and bag their daily limit early.
What they saw on their way was much more haunting.
The two hunters headed out on Sunday morning, November 19, 1978, to their chosen ridgeline on Little Buckhorn Creek near Noble. As they drove up the roadway, they saw something lying in the gravel beside the road in a “wide spot” near the boundary of the University of Kentucky property.
They slowed, and a closer look revealed that it was a body.
According to reports, the body was located at 6:45 a.m. near the mouth of Little Buckhorn off Highway 476. Sheriff Elliott Herald and Deputy Sheriff William A. “Widge” Herald rushed to the scene and secured it. Kentucky State Police Detective Orlando Noble, Jr. arrived and opened an investigation.
A quick look around the area and at the body revealed that the victim was a young African-American woman with approximately six gunshot wounds in various parts of her body. Five empty 45-caliber shell casings also lay nearby.
Officials determined that the woman had been driven to the location and killed beside the roadway.
Noble and Sheriff Herald estimated that the woman was between 25 and 30 years old and about 5 feet, six inches tall. They estimated her weight at 130 pounds, with brown eyes and black hair.
They carefully cataloged her clothing, believing her attire to be one of the keys to identifying their victim. Her gray coat, pink sweater, tan shoes, and Levi’s dungarees would later help identify her. A search of her pockets turned up nothing to help identify her. They did find an “emergency dime” in one of her shoes, which, they believed, indicated that she had access to a payphone.
Officials collected the evidence at the scene, and the Breathitt County Coroner transported the body to the Louisville General Hospital for a full autopsy.
Doctors with the Pathology Department at Louisville located another bullet wound during the autopsy and carefully documented the seven wounds they found. They located two .45 pistol slugs still lodged in her body.
A few days later, law enforcement officers in Lexington called Sheriff Herald. They informed him that the clothing had been identified by two female friends. They had given an identification after reviewing the photo of the victim taken at the scene by Deputy Herald.
The two witnesses told Lexington investigators that the woman was Carol Jean Benton, 21, of Winburn Drive in Lexington and that they had last seen her at 8:00 p.m. on Saturday, November 18.
Benton’s parents, John F. and Bobbie Jean Benton, also identified the woman in the photo as their daughter.
The Bentons claimed her body and funeral services were conducted on Saturday, November 25. She was buried in the Highland Memorial Cemetery off Lilse Industry Road in Lexington.
The Lexington Police Department joined the case, and some learned that Benton was known in the community as a “lady of the night” and was “working” when she was “picked up by a trick.” They believed that she was driven to Breathitt County and murdered by someone that she knew.
The Breathitt County Sheriff’s Office announced that a suspect has been identified by the Lexington Police Department as the “woman’s boyfriend” who “just happened to own a .45 automatic pistol.”
In November and December 1978, three “prostitution-related slayings” were reported in the area. Lexington Police Officers stepped up their patrols of the section of the city where Benton was “picked up.” The following month, they announced the arrest of eight prostitutes, six women and two men. Rumors circulated about a man who may have committed multiple murders of prostitutes, but no suspect was identified.

The case of Carol Jean Benton went silent in Breathitt County and was eventually forgotten in Lexington too.
No record of an arrest or prosecution has been found, and Benton’s killer or killers never met with justice.
While she was not a Breathitt County native, her name and untimely death were added to the list of unsolved murders that helped keep the sad and bloody record of Breathitt County alive well into our own time.
© 2026 by Stephen D. Bowling
Some images were enhanced using artificial intelligence.


